Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search

Lords of Gondor  by Linaewen 212 Review(s)
JaneReviewed Chapter: 58 on 7/15/2021
I really love this fic! You stayed wonderfully true to the characters and I lobe reading about Boromir survive! Great job, would be really happy if you get to continue it at some point! So curious/scared about your take on the brothers reuniting!

demeter dReviewed Chapter: 58 on 3/8/2021
I am happy to see that you continue this story! As I have said before, I love your Durlin! If Tolkien's Denethor had him in his corner, perhaps things would have turned out much differently. And I agree with the other reviewer. I do believe Gandalf draws hope and good energy from his "Fool of a Took". I have long believed that Gandalf very much loves his Hobbits.

Agape4rivendellReviewed Chapter: 45 on 10/1/2020
First, I have a soft spot for Imrahil. It is always a delight to see him in any tale. Loved his questioning Denethor and the respect the two have of each other. And Gandalf farewelling Faramir was perfect. It felt good to know Gandalf sent him off with words of encouragement. And finally, Boromir is on Gondor land. Phew! Wasn’t sure he’d make it. Thank you!

Agape4rivendellReviewed Chapter: 44 on 10/1/2020
My goodness.... what a treat. I did not realize you were posting chapters. So glad I came to read Katzillas and decided to see what you’ve been up to. A glorious chapter. I noticed, in some comments, that someone said reading Lords of Gondor was like reading the master, himself. Love every word of this chapter. The Rohirrim, Boromir's men, Pippin and Gandalf... and Faramir. Exquisite. Blessings.

demeter dReviewed Chapter: 57 on 8/14/2020
I am often glad that this site lets us do more than one review per chapter. Oops, the one with the loom is VAIRE, of course, not Varda! And, also, i am glad you are still traveling along with this story!

demeter dReviewed Chapter: 57 on 8/13/2020
For an enjoyable take on the fresh south wind blowing up from the sea, go read Chapter 21, called "Breath of Arda" in Fiondil's "Tales From Varda's Loom." He suggests that Manwe and the Valar sent that wind to aid the cause of those on the side of Light. A hopeful story, just as this one is.

Author Reply: Thank you for reading, and thanks so much for the heads up about Fiondil's story -- I will definitely go read that, I love his work and how he always seemed to write with hope.

Bob GormanReviewed Chapter: 58 on 4/10/2020
Can't wait for this story to keep going. I can't wait to see the Boromir/Aragorn reunion!

LindeleaReviewed Chapter: 2 on 2/11/2020
Have finally been able to carve out time for fanfic again, and so glad I saw this on the first page at SoA today! I am only at the beginning, but I have to say I love the way you've turned Boromir's familiar death scene into something much more hopeful. Looking forward to reading more.

LarnerReviewed Chapter: 58 on 2/10/2020
Indeed Hope is kindled, and hopefully Denethor will man up at this reassurance.

So good to see this continued!

LarnerReviewed Chapter: 57 on 2/10/2020
The various threads of the story now knit together to begin the tale of the Battle of the Pelennor. Now, to see it played out with the addition of Boromir and his men.

First Page | Previous Page | Next Page | Last Page

Return to Chapter List